Locked.

Locked.

My Twitter account is now locked.  I did not make this decision carelessly or without forethought.  Some readers will be surprised, others understanding, a few will tweet passive aggressive messages that condemn but don’ t mention me by name, and most people won’t care.

So why did I make my account private?

Back in the summer of 2008 when I signed up for Twitter, there weren’t many people I knew using the service, and the only way to really build a Twitter community was with a public account.  When I organized the AsburyPop event, I created an additional account to spread the word and build the brand, a goal that’s success depended upon an account being public.  At the time, I engaged online only on Twitter and didn’t open a Facebook account until late 2009, a fairly typical timeline for someone my age.  Eventually, I discovered LinkedIn and over time found it to be a very useful, engaging, and professional social media option.

During the past 3 years, my Twitter communities grew along with Twitter itself.  I now have over 2000 followers and at the start of the summer, followed slighly less than 2000 accounts.  I still maintained the AsburyPop account, renamed to VoxPopNJ (my company name), but rarely posted there.  My social media experience was too fragmented, and I lacked a clear “path forward” for my online activities, a concept a former boss and mentor from my younger days always said was critical to the success of any project. At the beginning of July, I consolidated my wordpress.com blog with my lauragesin.net and voxpopnj.com websites to create the site you see here, and about 2 weeks ago, I shut down the VoxPopNJ account.

As I cleared away the clutter surrounding my social media network, I took the next step and began vetting who I followed on Twitter.  No, I didn’t use those bulk unfollow services, I attempted to go through each and every account I followed to evaluate whether that account provided value for me and to my community.  I unfollowed over 200 accounts before abandoning that time consuming task.  My real community lies in my 2 Twitter lists, Top-Twitterers (307 accounts) and Fantastic Fiber Folks (24 accounts – I knit & recently started sewing again, and these twitterers share those passions). Those 331 accounts represent real, genuine people, most of whom I converse with on a daily basis.

Anyone reading my Twitter stream without reading the tweets of my community get one side of the conversation and comments out of context. If you aren’t friend or family – online or in real life – most of my posts make little sense.  I tweet fewer informative links than I used to, and probably chat directly with far fewer than 311 accounts.  Some members of my community are leaders in their field and wouldn’t recognize my avatar, but when one of them, oh say @JohnBirmingham, does respond directly to me, I’m thrilled.  (I won’t tell you what I did when @CoryBooker DM’d me.)

It’s important to note that those 331 accounts are not current students although many are teachers and educators.  I used to believe that the transparency of Twitter made me a better teacher, and to some extent, I still believe this.  When my students see me as more than a teacher, as a mother, a programmer, a designer, a daughter (I brought my parents to speak to a class 2 years ago), a friend (not to them but to people like @mswas and @NJFilm2011), a reader, a news junkie (cue pretentious NPR music), a traveler, a citizen, and yes, an adult who sometimes drops an f-bomb or two, they are more receptive to what I try to teach them and more understanding of my imperfections.

Until this past year, my students had little interest in Twitter.  Now, they tweet entire class experiences, are interested in what I and other teachers tweet, and use that as an easy means to ask quick questions.  I follow few students – those handful I do follow tend to be hard core coders or incredibly talented designers, and we discuss obscure programs and our obsession with fonts (and knitting) – and now won’t follow any until they graduate. Last week, a student mentioned me on Twitter asking if he could get into one of my classes at the last minute.  I don’t follow him, he doesn’t follow me, but Twitter was the quickest way for him to get his answer, and I wanted that to continue, a large part of why I haven’t “gone private” in the past.

Unfortunately, that will stop today.

Why? I don’t want an issue to arise regarding with I tweet because I earn my living primarily by teaching high school juniors and seniors.  We’ve all read the articles about teachers in trouble for online antics.  I didn’t see “paragon of virtue” in my employment contract, and I’m a huge fan of free speech.  I wonder how teachers that protested the Vietnam war or spoke out about racism before and during the Civil Rights movement were treated? Not that I tweet anything so lofty, but free speech is free speech, and I think students gain from knowing their teachers are people too. However, with students, parents, fellow teachers, and employers now active on social media – it worries me when my employer wants to be my friend on Facebook –  I have to find a compromise between what I believe is right and what’s expected of me.

The social media landscape went from the promise of the vast frontier to the confines of suburbia, and I’m moving to the gated community.

In my search for a new home online, I explored a number of possibilities.  Earlier this summer, I wrote a post about Ravelry, another social media network I’ve come to love.  I have few Ravelry friends, am a member of a number of groups, and post less than once a week, but I’ve come to love it as much as all the other social media platforms on which I engage.  Why? Because I can find what appears to be limitless information and instruction about the crafts I love, I can keep track of my projects, patterns I’d like to make, discover the experiences of other knitters, and follow my favorite podcasters’ adventures in fiber, literature, and their lives here and abroad.

It was that type of experience that drew me to Twitter, the small community of people with shared interests and experiences who aren’t intrusive, judgemental or spammy.  I’ve lost that aspect of Twitter, and I hope to get it back by taking control of my account. I’ve found it to some extent on Google+ (more about that in a future post).  In a moment of panic, I thought going private meant losing access to an online outlet that’s completely public.  Then I remembered! What is my blog other than an public platform for the expression of my interests, opinions and experiences?

All relationships require work, and it’s time I gave Twitter some much needed attention.  The first step? Locking my account and actively managing my community.  The second? Making this blog the focal point of my online expression.

 

4 Comments

  1. Amie
    Aug 22, 2011

    Where to begin! You’ve said so much that I can completely relate to. I mean, EVERYTHING. I’m just going to respond as I re-read what you’ve said:

    “Cleaning clutter”- I could see from the start of social media that there could be a huge pile-up of social “friends,” so when people started following me, I quickly came up with some guidelines for following back. I have this tentative blog post brewing (been sitting around for awhile now) about this very topic. I think it’ll be…a little controversial for some. It just needs some polishing. Maybe I’ll get on that ASAP since it’s in my mind.

    Transparency of Twitter (or any social media network): You know what I do for a living. I’m in that same boat about having to think about what you say online. I admit fully to being paranoid about the things I say and do online, at least in places that are cached on Google. And I feel I have reason to be, considering how admins, parents, students etc are on these same sites.

    FB: To that extent, I never friend past/present students, faculty, admins, or staff with 3 exceptions because we were friends outside of work. I know, paranoid. And, I must admit, when I see one of them friend someone I know – a student, another teacher – I go to that account and block it so that I don’t get a friend request from that person. The day that I saw my admin’s face pop up on the right side column suggesting that I friend that person, I panicked. That meant that someone I know friended that admin and if I ever say anything on my friend’s page, that admin will see it. I DON’T WANT THAT! I feel like this: when I go home, I’m home. I don’t want to know work exists until I’m back at it. I don’t want my home “sphere” to cross over my work “sphere.” Ever. Needless to say, my block list on FB is a mile long.

    Rav is great place to hang out. I don’t ever see it dying out like I do FB, Twitter, etc. The fact that you, as a user, can have control to create your own group is awesome. Just think of all the combinations and permutations that exist within that framework. I mean, there are SO MANY groups on there already! I’ve been on Rav since nearly the inception – close enough anyways – that I’ve seen the progress that it’s made. There is no other online community like it (I’m convinced anyways) that allows the freedom that this one does coupled with a shared interest in knit/crochet/dying/spinning/weaving.

    So in the end, I totally understand why you’d want to take back a little control over your online experience on Twitter by locking it. I’m careful what I say there. I don’t even use my real name in my profile. Someone would have to take a couple leaps to figure out who I am and at that point, I can say that I’m not saying anything there that I wouldn’t say out loud in person. I’ve ridden that line since inception and will continue to do so.

    G+ is my newest foray and with that, I’m treading very lightly. I don’t feel a need to be on there saying stuff every day. And I *think* I have it kinda locked down enough and my name slightly obscured enough that I won’t find myself popping up in search engines. My brand name, yes. My real name, I hope not.

    • admin
      Aug 22, 2011

      Thanks for such a considerate response! I’m a believer in transparency – WYSIWYG applied to people – but am having the same issues you recount on Facebook and here on Twitter. In a perfect world, tolerance and understanding would rule the day, and the Howard Stern approach – if you don’ t like what I’m saying, don’t read my blog, posts, etc. – hasn’t been embraced as much as I would hope. I too don’t engage on G+ as often as other sites, but the engagement there seems to be more rewarding, less shallow, with few lurkers & little spam (at least so far).

      Only time will tell if this decision brings me the online privacy and offline lack of drama I intended by locking the account. I’d say that’s a future blog post!

  2. Robin
    Aug 22, 2011

    An excellent and thought-provoking post. The online world offers so many wonderful opportunities to connect with others who share your passions (Ravelry!) but it is also incredibly dynamic and potentially threatening. I hope we can glean the best and avoid the rest!

  3. Square-Peg Karen
    Aug 24, 2011

    Brilliant! I was nodding “yes, yes, YES!” as I read along, and will go back to re-read and process (figure out how this works for me/what I want to do regarding controlling my own social media use) over the next few days.

    I haven’t had a lot of contact with you, Laura – but each time I’ve read your blog or tweets I’ve come away with something – you seem to be a DEEP person & I adore deep people!

    This post is an example of what I mean — the way you take us through your thoughts on your use of social media, without a harping/cranky attitude – just thinking – deeply – ah, I love it!

    AND I’m leaving your post not only with something to mull over (I love mulling – lol), but also with a plan to recheck my (poor, abandoned) LinkedIn, Ravelry and Google+ accounts! Hey, I might even pick my knitting needles up again (and the weather’s nice now, I won’t even get stuck to the wool).

    Thanks so much for sharing your depth with us!!!

Submit a Comment

CommentLuv badge